Best Rated Toaster Ovens 2024 Rated. Based on our tests, these are the best toaster ovens you can buy right now, including some of the best air fryer. We used these machines to bake hundreds of cookies and dozens of meatballs and toasted countless bagels and slices of bread.

Our top pick is the. To find the best toaster oven, we consulted two experts and tested nine units for temperature consistency and accuracy, preheating and cooking speed, and ease of use.